Fed Policy Doesn’t Directly Control Mortgage Rates

Most people assume the Federal Reserve sets the interest rate on their mortgage, but that is a common misconception. The central bank controls the federal funds rate, which is the rate banks charge each other overnight, but it does not dictate the 30-year fixed mortgage rate. That number is determined in a completely different market where investors trade mortgage-backed securities and long-term debt. When headlines announce a Fed rate change, it rarely affects the mortgage rate the same day, and it certainly does not mean the cost of a home loan has gone up or down for a buyer.

Related: Seahawks Vet Launches Spokane Firm

The Fed sets a target range for the federal funds rate, and this single number ripples outward to affect short-term borrowing costs. That includes the prime rate, which in turn influences credit card balances, auto loans, and home equity lines of credit. If a person carries a balance on a variable-rate credit card, they are very much affected by Fed meetings. These are short-term instruments, and short-term money is the Fed’s domain. However, a 30-year fixed mortgage is a different animal. Rather than staying on the lender’s books, most mortgages are bundled with thousands of others and sold to investors as mortgage-backed securities. Those securities compete with other long-term investments, like Treasury bonds, and their prices are set by investors around the world.

The mortgage you sign is ultimately part of a bond that trades in a global market, and that market — not the Federal Reserve — sets the rate a borrower gets. That does not make the Fed irrelevant; its policies shape inflation, growth, and where investors think rates are heading, all of which feeds the bond market. But the effect on mortgages is indirect. Mortgage rates answer to what investors believe is coming, not to what the Fed announces on a given afternoon. Because of this disconnect, buyers often wait for a Fed cut that was never going to help them, and sellers misjudge their timing. Even seasoned business owners tend to treat the federal funds rate and the 30-year mortgage as the same lever, when they are not.

Related: June power generation falls for 13th straight year

If you want a single number that tracks where mortgage rates are heading, ignore the Fed and watch the yield on the 10-year Treasury note. The relationship is not perfect, but it is close, and it holds for a sensible reason. Investors treat mortgage bonds and Treasurys as competing places to park long-term money. When Treasury yields climb, mortgage rates have to climb too, or nobody would accept the added risk of a home loan over the safety of government debt. This dynamic explains why inflation news moves mortgage rates so sharply. Inflation is the enemy of anyone holding a fixed payment over years, since it erodes the value of every dollar that comes back, and a hot inflation report can push rates higher before the Fed even says a word.

The spread between the 10-year yield and the mortgage rate is a separate force that often moves on its own. Today’s mortgage spread sits above its long-term average. If it simply drifted back to normal, mortgage rates would fall with no action from the Fed at all. This spread covers the mortgage lifecycle: originating the loan, guaranteeing it, servicing it, and selling it on. It also covers a risk somewhat unique in fixed income; a homeowner can refinance any time rates fall, leaving the investor to reinvest the money at a lower yield. Yet, if rates rise, that same homeowner keeps paying the old low rate for years. The investor bears the downside in both directions. Nobody accepts that bet for free, so they demand extra yield, and that premium widens whenever market volatility spikes. The spread acts as a second lever on your rate; one that has nothing to do with the Fed, and it can move on its own.

Related: Mead Works Begins Multifamily Construction Phase

When a client tells me they are waiting for the Fed to rescue their rate, they are often waiting for the wrong thing. Rates can improve because inflation cools, because global investors grow hungrier for American bonds, because Treasury yields fall, or because a stretched spread finally relaxes. Any of those can happen while the Fed sits perfectly still. The opposite is just as true, which is why a rate can jump the same afternoon the Fed announces a cut, catching everyone who was watching the wrong number. The next time a Fed announcement takes over the headlines, don’t assume your mortgage rate will move because of it. Watch the bond market instead: the 10-year yield, the inflation reports that move it, and the spread riding on top. That is where the price of a mortgage is really decided, every trading day, long before the phone in my office starts to ring.